Peek A Boo PEEPS Cookies
Soft brown sugar sandwich cookies with frosting and Peeps.
This Giveaway is CLOSED. A winner has been chosen and the prize(s) have been fulfilled.
You cannot deny that Peeps are an Easter icon, and these Peek-a-Boo Peeps Cookies are just perfect for your Easter table! I had so much fun with last year’s Peek-a-Book Peeps Cupcakes that I had to cookie them. **Here’s a fun fact… As stated in that post you’ll see further inspiration came from Amanda at I am Baker with her Peeps Cake Pops.** I just can’t quit beheading Peeps. And I just love how these little guys look like they are all puffed out in the middle of the cookie, peeking through.
You can make these with any homemade or store-bought cookie but today I’m giving you my recipe for THE BEST, soft, chewy, giant Biscoff Cookies in all the land. In a moment of pure evil genius, I sandwiched them together with marshmallow fluff.
If you don’t know my story, the short version is this: I’m a peanut butter addict whose son was diagnosed with a peanut allergy so I bake with Biscoff spread as a peanut butter alternative. I have lots and lots of Biscoff recipes if you’re looking. For those who may be wondering- I usually purchase Biscoff in the peanut butter aisle at Wal-Mart or my local grocery store.
Giant Chewy Biscoff Cookies (with Peeps)
Ingredients
- 1 Cup 2 sticks butter
- 1 Cup brown sugar
- 1 Cup granulated sugar
- 1 1/2 Cups Biscoff spread
- 2 eggs
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 2 1/2 Cups flour
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- Additional sugar
Optional
- Marshmallow Fluff
- Sprinkles
- Peeps
Instructions
- Combine butter, sugars, and Biscoff and mix until smooth in the bowl of your mixer.
- In a separate bowl combine the flour and baking soda.
- Add eggs and vanilla to the mixer. Then slowly incorporate the dry ingredients. Dough will be wet. For best results refrigerate for at least 30 minutes to 1 hour.
- Form dough into 1 inch balls and roll in sugar. Place on ungreased cookie sheet and bake at 350°F for about 15 minutes or until firm and golden brown.
This Giveaway is CLOSED. A winner has been chosen and the prize(s) have been fulfilled.
Want to win your own GIANT BOX of PEEPS?
Tell me (in the comments section) what is your favorite way to enjoy Peeps and click on the Rafflecopter entry form that says you commented. BOOM! You’re entered! If you want some bonus entries you can follow me and some of these delicious blogs I’ve partnered with. Just use the Rafflecopter entry below (US residents only, please). Remember to be patient, the Rafflecopter widget can be slow to load.
- PEEPS bunnies in Chocolate Easter Eggs from The Decorated Cookie
- PEEPS Cupcakes from Hoosier Homemade
- Spring PEEPS Truffles from Java Cupcake
- Pavlova Peeps Nests from Crazy for Crust
- PEEPS S’mores from The Southern Institute
- Giant PEEPS Cereal Treat from Dollhouse Bake Shoppe
- PEEPS Candy Bars from The Domestic Rebel
- Rice Krispies PEEPS from Creative Food
- Easter Cake with White Chocolate PEEPS from Bird on a Cake
- Hula Bunny PEEPS from Sugar Swings! Serve Some
- Peeping Peeps from Miss Candiquik
- Bird House S’mores on a Stick From Kitchen Fun with My Three Sons
- Layered S’mores Brownies with PEEPS from Shugary Sweets
- PEEPS Brownie Pops from Munchkin Munchies
- Easter PEEPS in their Finest from Pint Sized Baker
- Peeps Get Married from Haniela’s
- Peek A Boo PEEPS Cookies from In Katrina’s Kitchen
- Spring Hop Along PEEPS Party from Love From the Oven
- PEEPS Eclair Cake Cups from Inside BruCrew Life
- PEEPS Easter Candy Carrots from Hungry Happenings
- Very Vanilla PEEPS Cake from Pink Little Cake
- Peeps Centerpiece Cookies from The Baked Equation
- PEEPS Magician Hat from Not Your Momma’s Cookie
Disclosure: This is not a sponsored post, we just love Peeps ♥ Special thanks to Michelle from Sugar Swings Serve Some and Christi from Love from the Oven for organizing the Peeps Party!
74 Comments on “Peek A Boo PEEPS Cookies”
Eating them plain. Cute enough to share and enjoy.
i could use a bunch of these right about now! can i behead peeps with you next time?? thanks so much for playing along!!
Oh katrina, these are adorable. I want one! or a dozen!!!
hehehe, omg these are too cute! Such a fantastic addition to the Peeps party! So glad we got to collaborate 😀
-Lindsay Ann @ Dollhouse Bake Shoppe
I like Peeps with ice cream.
I love my peeps stale!
Biscoff and Peeps together??? A match made in heaven!
I like to microwave peeps until they are puffed and gooey.
ooh cuteness!
I like them a little stale – open the box and let them sit out all day, that way they are a little crusty. Crazy sweetness! Glad there here just once a year! But can’t wait to try out this recipe!
Ha! For decoration!
Just the way they are or on a popsicle stick for the kiddos.
I have a similar story too– PB lover turned to now WOWBUTTER and Soynutbutter and of course Biscoff lover bc of my daughter’s Peanut allergy! 🙂 LOVE your Peek-a-boo-PEEPS cookies!!
I love my peeps a bit stale and crunchy on the outside.
I love to eat them with peanut butter and chocolate.
I like eating them right out of the package!
I love my peeps any way I can get’em!
I like them right out of the package.
I like to use my Peeps for s’mores!
I love chocolate covered peeps!!!
I like peeps!
Open mouth – insert 1 entire peep. SQUISH and smile 🙂 looove the texture and slight crunch of peeps.
Right out of the package.
Aww these are so cute!!
I like my peeps stale!!
these are by FAR the cutest cookies I ever have seen Katrina. You rock! and the biscoff – oh lordy my head is spinning in delight 😉 I looooove biscoff!
I love these cookies, Katrina! From their adorable faces to that peekaboo swirl of sugary marshmallow oozing from the cookie–delish!
These sound wonderful! Love the bottoms!
These are adorable! You are so creative!
Straight out of the package!!
Biscoff cookies sound super yummy!!! and peep a boo Peeps is such a great idea
I enjoy Peeps plain but would like to try them as a smore.
Haha – so cute!!
I like savoring them by taking little bites!
I have to say that I am a huge fan of biscoff, and cookies made from biscoff well that’s even better. These peek-a-boo peeps are so adorable 🙂
Aww..peep a boo…how cute!!
Oh Katrina. I think I’m going to love you forever for these cookies…
I forgot to tell you – I like them dried out!! 🙂
How cute – love the little “peep” a boo! 🙂
I like to microwave them and eat them with a fork – soft and gooey.
I like them stale a bit so they’re like taffy!
These are adorable! Well-done, my friend. Love the cookies!
Right out of the package:)
I like biting their little heads off first, ha!
Me too! 🙂
I’m a fan of stale Peeps, the chewier the better! I love Biscoff cookies and have some spread in my pantry and will have to try this recipe. Sounds great.
I really want to try biscoff now!
I like them after they have hardened out of the package for a few days so the outsides are slightly crunchy!
Katrina, those are stinking adorable! LOL I love that you behead your Peeps! I think those Biscoff cookies sound amazing too…so big and so yummy!!!
Right out of the package!
not original, but i just like them the way they are!